Buying and selling used electric cars: a recent inspection, but how healthy is the battery?
Imagine two electric cars brought from Germany to Estonia. They’re the same model, from the same year, with the same mileage. Both have just passed their roadworthiness inspection. One costs €1,000 more and is advertised as having a ‘battery in very good condition’. I’d be willing to pay more for a better battery. First, though, I’d want to see how the seller knows their car has the better one.
Germany’s TÜV report, published on 18 November, gives that question unexpected weight. Its authors analysed 9.7 million passenger car roadworthiness inspections. Inspectors found major defects in 3.0% of two- to three-year-old Mazda MX-30 electric cars. For Tesla Model Ys of the same age, the figure was 18.5%, more than six times as high. These results tell us nothing about the remaining battery capacity of either model. Germany’s periodic roadworthiness inspection checks the high-voltage battery mainly by visual inspection.
The same Mazda shows why the inspection is still useful. TÜV SÜD looked separately at five-year-old MX-30 electric cars with an average mileage of just 45,000 kilometres. It found a major defect involving the brake discs in 3.3% of them. A buyer who has found a Mazda with a healthy battery now has a good idea of what to ask a mechanic to check before buying. The same logic works the other way round: if a car has a clean inspection report, it’s worth finding out how much energy its battery can still store today.
What does ‘battery 90%’ mean in an advert?
A reading of 90% on the dashboard tells the driver how full the battery is right now. In a sales advert, it’s a different figure that matters. When used to assess capacity, the battery’s State of Health (SoH) shows how much of the usable energy capacity it had when new remains. Even an ageing battery can be charged to 100%.
Take a car whose battery had a usable capacity of 60 kWh when new. If 90% of that remains, the driver can count on roughly 54 kWh. At an illustrative consumption of 20 kWh per 100 kilometres, the difference of 6 kWh translates to about 30 kilometres of range. For someone who charges at home every night and drives 40 kilometres a day, the cheaper car may be the better buy. For a driver who already reaches the next charger with little range to spare on a typical winter run out of town, those same kilometres may be worth the difference in price.
That’s why, as a buyer, I’d want to know who tested the battery, what method they used, when they did it and what the odometer read at the time. A quick test and a longer capacity test based on data collected while driving offer different levels of accuracy. Even a properly conducted test only describes the battery’s condition at the time. A report from two years and 40,000 kilometres ago is a useful part of the car’s history, but I’d want something more recent when negotiating today’s price.
Who should pay for the test?
The seller has a fair objection. Testing costs money, and no single day of testing can say exactly how many more years the battery will last. I think it’s perfectly reasonable for the seller to state in the advert that the battery capacity hasn’t been measured. The two sides can then agree whether the buyer wants to arrange a test before the sale and who will pay for it.
But if the justification for charging an extra €1,000 is that the battery is ‘in very good condition’, the seller should arrange the test. The owner of a well-maintained car also has the most to gain: they can show why their car is worth choosing over another. As a buyer, I’d ask the seller for two documents when I went for a test drive. I’d check the inspection report for any findings on the brakes and running gear. In the battery report, I’d look for a reason to pay that extra €1,000.