Advertisement

Euro NCAP warns over urban truck safety as three of seven miss CitySafe requirements

Crash test
Fullscreen image

Euro NCAP tested seven trucks designed for urban logistics and found significant shortcomings in their protection of pedestrians and cyclists. DAF, Isuzu and IVECO missed out on the CitySafe award recognising safety in urban traffic. The MAN TGL achieved the best result with five stars. The most surprising finding, however, was that none of the trucks tested had an active lane-keeping assistance system.

Advertisement

MAN shows what a modern urban truck can achieve

On 3 November, Euro NCAP published safety test results for seven distribution trucks weighing around 12 tonnes. The tests focused on driver visibility, collision avoidance and the protection of pedestrians and cyclists.

The five-star MAN TGL scored 89% in the Safe Driving category and 71% in Collision Avoidance.

MAN's strengths were good direct vision, optional digital mirrors with an adaptive field of view, and effective autonomous emergency braking. The system for detecting cyclists travelling alongside the truck as it turns performed particularly well. Unlike some competitors' systems, it does not rely on the indicator being used.

The Volvo FL and Renault Trucks D both earned four stars and the CitySafe award. Both scored 62% for Collision Avoidance.

The Mercedes-Benz Atego also finished with four stars, standing out for its extensive standard equipment, but trailing MAN in Collision Avoidance with a score of 56%.

IVECO Eurocargo ranks last for collision avoidance

The IVECO Eurocargo, Isuzu F-Series and DAF XB achieved the weakest results.

IVECO earned two stars and just 20% of the available points for Collision Avoidance. Its autonomous emergency braking performed satisfactorily in avoiding vehicle-to-vehicle collisions, but several important functions were missing in the pedestrian and cyclist protection tests.

The Isuzu F-Series also received two stars, scoring 29% for Collision Avoidance. Interestingly, it offered the best direct vision from the cab of any truck in the comparison. Slim pillars and a deep windscreen gave the driver a good view, but the electronic safety systems did not do enough to complement that advantage.

The DAF XB achieved three stars and 36% for Collision Avoidance. Its main shortcoming was the lack of a system to prevent collisions with cyclists when turning.

In Euro NCAP's assessment, trucks such as these, with their current safety equipment, are better suited to routes with lighter traffic than to busy urban environments.

All lacked lane-keeping assistance

One of the test's most important findings concerned lane keeping.

None of the seven trucks offered an active system to help steer the vehicle back into its lane if it drifted out unintentionally.

This is a notable omission, because distribution trucks do not operate solely on city streets. They also frequently travel on motorways and faster urban roads, where driver distraction can cause a serious accident.

However, a distinction must be made between lane departure warning and active steering intervention. Euro NCAP primarily criticised the absence of the latter.

Advertisement

According to Matthew Avery, the safety organisation's director of strategic development, the MAN TGL's result shows that effective active safety systems and good visibility can be combined in this truck class too.

All seven trucks compared

Truck

Safe Driving

Collision Avoidance

Stars

CitySafe

MAN TGL

89%

71%

5

Yes

Volvo FL

78%

62%

4

Yes

Renault Trucks D

78%

62%

4

Yes

Mercedes-Benz Atego

77%

56%

4

Yes

DAF XB

66%

36%

3

No

Isuzu F-Series

67%

29%

2

No

IVECO Eurocargo

58%

20%

2

No

All seven trucks scored 80% in the Post-Crash Safety category. The main differences in their ratings therefore came down to visibility and active collision avoidance systems.

The results are particularly important for urban traffic

Urban logistics trucks travel every day through areas where pedestrians, cyclists and cars share limited street space.

Right turns, junctions and manoeuvring on narrow streets are particularly challenging for truck drivers. A high cab, the vehicle's dimensions and limited direct vision make it difficult to spot nearby road users.

Euro NCAP's results show that good visibility alone does not guarantee maximum safety. In Isuzu's case, the cab design worked in the driver's favour, but inadequate electronic assistance systems reduced the overall score.

Nor can cameras alone compensate for a weak emergency braking system.

For European transport operators and local authorities, the results provide an additional way to assess trucks' suitability for urban work. The CitySafe award could be particularly important when procuring refuse trucks, goods vehicles and other vehicles that frequently manoeuvre in heavy traffic.

Urban truck safety is not determined by driver experience alone

Euro NCAP's comparison reveals a significant gap in the safety capabilities of trucks designed for the same purpose.

All seven models perform similar transport tasks, but their active safety systems differ substantially. MAN's 71% and IVECO's 20% scores for Collision Avoidance are particularly telling.

This does not mean that an IVECO will necessarily be involved in more accidents. Euro NCAP's tests measure how specific systems perform in defined situations, not vehicles' actual accident rates.

The study's main conclusion is nevertheless clear: the development of urban truck safety equipment has not reached the same level across all manufacturers. This applies particularly to pedestrian and cyclist protection, where electronic systems must also be capable of preventing dangerous situations caused by driver inattention.

With freight volumes growing in European cities, these differences are becoming increasingly important.